The chance for debate in Major League Baseball never ends. The individual awards were just handed out, and as if on cue, here comes the announcement for the 2015 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot ready to provide the next topic sure to spark discussion and more than a little disagreement.
There are plenty of subplots to consider—will Craig Biggio get in after missing by a mere two votes last time? what happens to those with links to performance-enhancing drugs (whether rumored or real)? which players will the ongoing bottleneck hurt most?—but the focus here is on one new name to the list, in particular.
Of the three big-name pitchers added to the this year's Hall of Fame ballot—Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez and John Smoltz—the first two are no-doubt first-ballot entries. The third has a great chance of being voted in too, but his case isn't quite as open-and-shut by comparison.
As impressive as Smoltz was over his 21 years in Major League Baseball, his accomplishments aren't on par with those of Johnson and Martinez. That shouldn't be held against Smoltz, of course, but it does mean he is overshadowed by two better pitchers—heck, two all-time greats—in year one.
That presents the possibility Smoltz might not make it to Cooperstown in his first go-around.
Johnson, who won five Cy Young Awards, including a record-tying four straight (1999-02), finished his 22-year career with 303 wins and 4,875 strikeouts, second most all time behind Nolan Ryan's 5,714.
Martinez, in his 18 seasons, posted the sixth-best winning percentage ever (.687) and owned a 2.93 ERA, 1.05 WHIP and 10.0 K/9. He also won the Cy three times (1997, 1999-00), with his very best seasons at the height of the steroid era in the late 1990s and early 2000s.
Those two? They're getting in, and they're likely getting upward of 95 percent of the vote as two of the very best in baseball history.
Plain as day, both Johnson and Martinez rank in the top 20 among pitchers, according to both versions of wins above replacement, fWAR (from FanGraphs) and rWAR (from Baseball-Reference.com). They were as good as it gets in their time—and rank right up there all time too.
Smoltz was dominant in his own right, and for a very long time—he's one of only 16 pitchers with 3,000 career strikeouts—but his career path was quite different from that of Johnson and Martinez.
A huge part of the Braves' success throughout the 1990s and into the early 2000s—remember, they won an unprecedented 14 consecutive division titles—Smoltz split his career between the rotation and the bullpen.
While both Johnson and Martinez started at least 85 percent of their career appearances, Smoltz worked in relief in 242 of his 723 games—or about 33 percent.
The switch from starter to reliever came late in his career, after Smoltz underwent Tommy John surgery and missed all of the 2000 season. He eventually did return to starting to wrap up his time in the majors.
"When I was playing, I wanted to win more than anything," Smoltz said via Barry Bloom of MLB.com. "I never really even contemplated any of those decisions when I changed direction in my career for the risk or reward of the Hall of Fame. That never even entered my mind."
That back-and-forth could work against Smoltz, even if the right-hander was an incredibly effective closer, compiling 154 saves, a 2.65 ERA and 1.02 WHIP in his four seasons in the pen (2001-04).
So could the fact that Smoltz wasn't the best pitcher on his own team for almost every one of his 21 seasons.
Again, however, that can't be held against the now 47-year-old, who just so happened to pitch alongside Greg Maddux and Tom Glavine—both of whom earned 90-plus percent of the vote to make the Hall as first-timers last year—for so much of his career.
Now that he's joining the ballot with Johnson and Martinez, Smoltz is once again overshadowed.
But this is more than just a player who can make a claim as the first—and still only—pitcher ever to have at least 200 wins (213) and 150 saves (154) in his career. Smoltz also won the 1996 NL Cy Young and has one of the very best playoff resumes around.
Only Andy Pettitte, with 19, has more postseason wins than Smoltz's 15. What's more, his 209.0 innings check in as the third most, and nobody has more than Smoltz's 199 strikeouts in October.
And here's that same fWAR/rWAR chart from above, only with Smoltz's fWAR and rWAR included too:
By either measure, Smoltz is a top-40 pitcher in MLB history, and he has a case for being in the top 25, at least in the context of FanGraphs.
Here's where one last wrench can be thrown when it comes to Smoltz's shot at getting into the Hall, especially on his first attempt.
Not counting Johnson and Martinez, of the 36 pitchers who rate ahead of Smoltz on the career rWAR list, there are six who are not enshrined, including Rick Reuschel, whose career began 16 years before Smoltz's did and Jim McCormick, whose career dates back to, well, practically the Civil War.
The other four, however, are contemporaries of Smoltz: Roger Clemens (139.5 fWAR/139.4 rWAR), Mike Mussina (82.5/82.7), Curt Schilling (83.2/80.7) and Kevin Brown (73.5/68.5).
This foursome represents a wide range of outcomes on the Hall of Fame voting scale, as Clemens has yet to make it in, only because of his PED-linked past; while Brown surprisingly failed to garner even the necessary 5 percent of votes in his first year and thus dropped off the ballot.
Mussina and Schilling both were stuck in the who-knows 20 percent territory last year and appear to be victims of the recent overload of worthy (or near-worthy) players that has hampered Baseball Writers Association of America voters who can choose only up to 10 players in a given year.
The guess here, though, is that the latter two eventually will get in—and deservedly so—and that Smoltz will receive a boost for his success as both a starter and a closer, even if that's more superficial than substantive.
There's also the chance Smoltz will get an extra push from being considered alongside former Braves rotation-mates Maddux and Glavine as well as longtime skipper Bobby Cox, all three of whom were inducted last year while Smoltz was in Cooperstown as an analyst for MLB Network.
"I thought it was one of the coolest things I have ever been a part of," Smoltz said via Bloom. "I mean that from a standpoint of even if I never get in."
Smoltz shouldn't have to worry about never getting in—he will. And it very well could happen on his first shot.
Ultimately, if the question is one of worthiness, when the results are announced on Jan. 6, 2015, Johnson, Martinez and Smoltz all should be in.
But given the number of Hall-worthy candidates still in the mix and that writers can vote for a maximum of 10 players—not to mention that Smoltz isn't quite the shoe-in Johnson and Martinez are and has a few contemporaries who aren't yet in—don't be surprised if Maddux and Glavine don't see their former teammate join them right away.
Regardless, Smoltz should be prepared to make a speech during the Hall of Fame's induction weekend. It just might not happen next July.
Statistics are accurate through the 2014 season and courtesy of MLB.com, Baseball-Reference.com and FanGraphs unless otherwise noted. Contract information courtesy of Spotrac.
To talk baseball or fantasy baseball, check in with me on Twitter: @JayCat11.
Read more MLB news on BleacherReport.com
- Login to post comments