The scramble for the National League Central is easily the most intriguing division race in baseball. And, with a tip of the cap to Spinal Tap, the intrigue is about to get cranked up to "11."
Entering play Monday, the St. Louis Cardinals (89-54) sit in first place, the Pittsburgh Pirates (86-56) are 2.5 games out in second place and the Chicago Cubs (82-60) are 6.5 games off the pace in third.
Chicago and Pittsburgh hold the NL's two wild-card slots. The Cubs trail the Bucs by four games for the No. 1 wild-card position, but they have a comfortable 7.5-game advantage over the next-closest club, the San Francisco Giants (75-68).
So all three of the NL Central's top squads are virtual locks to make the playoffs. But only one can win the division and avoid the dreaded do-or-die Wild Card Game.
And that's where the intrigue begins.
On Tuesday, the Cubs and Pirates kick off a crucial four-game series at PNC Park. Then, on Friday, the Cubs and Cardinals meet for three contests in the Windy City that should stoke the coals of a historic, smoldering rivalry.
How's it all going to play out? What will the NL Central landscape look like after the dust from this week's flurry of head-to-head clashes has settled?
Watch the games and find out, obviously. In the meantime, though, how about a little spirited speculation?
First, let's dissect that Pirates-Cubs series, the importance of which cannot be overstated.
With a sweep, the Cubbies could tie the Pirates for the No. 1 wild-card spot and put themselves within striking distance of the division crown.
On the other hand, with a sweep or even a series win, the Pirates could put some breathing room between themselves and Chicago and make a play for first place.
The Cubs lead the season series, 7-5. And they've got their top four starting pitchers—Jason Hammel, Jon Lester, Jake Arrieta and Kyle Hendricks—lined up to go, per ESPN's Jesse Rogers.
On the other hand, Pittsburgh is 49-22 at PNC Park, the best home winning percentage in baseball.
And the Bucs have momentum on their side, for what it's worth, having won three straight and seven of their last 10.
Ace Gerrit Cole is set to go in the first game of a doubleheader against Chicago on Tuesday. And on Wednesday, resurgent veteran A.J. Burnett will make his second start since coming off the disabled list.
The Cubs have also won seven of their last 10 (though they've lost two straight to the woeful Philadelphia Phillies) and have a respectable 39-32 road record this year.
I'm betting, however, that the Pirates take three of four on their home turf.
To put it simply, they've been here before—playing in each of the last two Wild Card Games—and in this case, experience wins out over a Cubs team full of newbies.
Of course, not every Cub is green. Lester, the seasoned left-hander Chicago inked this winter, has basked in postseason glory with the Boston Red Sox. He was also part of an October flame-out last autumn with the Oakland A's.
"It's fun to talk about, but I've been on both sides where we’ve been up and we gave it back and we've come from behind,” Lester said, per Rogers. "Anything is possible."
That might as well be the slogan for the whole division.
Speaking of which, let's move on to the Cubs-Cardinals collision. But first, let's parse the Cards.
While Pittsburgh and Chicago duke it out, St. Louis will play a three-game series in Milwaukee against the Brewers.
The Cardinals have been in a distressing tailspin, losing nine out of 13 games in September and watching their once-comfortable division lead deteriorate.
But the Cards are 8-4 against the Brewers this year. And an offense that was shut out twice between last Monday and Thursday could get healthy at Miller Park, the third-most hitter-friendly yard in the NL according to ESPN's Park Factors statistic.
Add the return of former offensive cog Matt Adams—who missed 91 games with a quadriceps injury but launched a pinch-hit home run Sunday as the Cards beat the Cincinnati Reds, 9-2—and you've got the makings of a minor offensive renaissance.
So let's say St. Louis nabs two of three from the Brewers in Milwaukee and rolls into its series in Chicago with a modest dollop of swagger.
That would seem to point toward a Cardinals triumph on the North Side; St. Louis owns the season series against Chicago 10-6, after all.
The Cubs, though, have been particularly tough in front of the ivy of late, winning 16 of their last 20 home games.
Even if they expend Arrieta, a legitimate NL Cy Young contender, in the Pirates series, I'll still call for the Cubs to claim two of three from St. Louis behind their young bats, including NL Rookie of the Year front-runner Kris Bryant, who's hitting .333 with six RBI over the past week.
Does that seem contradictory after I just dinged Chicago for its inexperience? Sure, but that's sort of the point: You can (often) count on young teams to be down one moment and up the next.
What are the Pirates up to at this point? They'll be playing a three-game set against the Los Angeles Dodgers in Southern California.
The bad news for Pittsburgh is that the Dodgers are the first-place team in the NL West. The worse news is that, with an off day Thursday, LA will be able to pitch its righty-lefty buzz saw of Zack Greinke and Clayton Kershaw against the Bucs.
As good as that pair has been, I'll bank on the Dodgers to win two of three at home.
So where does that leave us?
Under our revised hypothetical standings, the Cards are now 92-57, the Pirates are 90-59 and the Cubs are 85-64.
That, in turn, sets the stage for an epic three-game series between the Pirates and Cardinals beginning Sept. 28 in Pittsburgh. And the Cubs get another crack at the Bucs as well, with a three-game set that kicks off Sept. 25 in Chicago.
The bottom line, in case you hadn't gathered, is that this thing will go down to the wire. If I'm laying down money, I'll put it on the Pirates for reasons neatly summarized by ESPN's Christina Kahrl:
The Pirates have gone 20-10 in their past 30, compared to the Cardinals' 16-14 record in that same stretch. And a big part of the reason why has been pitching—they’ve given up a run per game less than the Cardinals, just 106 runs allowed to the Birds' 136. You can add in the Cards’ recent offensive struggles, scoring just 23 runs in their 10 games before Sunday’s 9-2 win over the Reds, a stretch in which they lost eight of 10 games. In that same stretch, the Cubs are 18-12, but their games have been more sloppy slugfests with the Cubs plating 164 runs while allowing 140.
Then again, the Cards have found a way to reach at least the National League Championship Series in each of the last four seasons. And discount those upstart, hard-charging Cubs at your own peril.
The games will go back and forth. Pulses will rise, and blood may indeed boil.
"In this division, nobody likes each other," Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said, per Stephen J. Nesbitt of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. "We all respect one another, but nobody likes each other."
Translation: Check that intrigue nob as September unfolds, because it might be cranking rapidly toward "12."
All standings and head-to-head records current as of Sept. 13 and courtesy of MLB.com.
Read more MLB news on BleacherReport.com
- Login to post comments